[R] Is R good for not-professional-statistician, un-mathematical clinical researchers?
ernesto at ipimar.pt
Thu Aug 19 11:08:44 CEST 2004
On Thu, 2004-08-19 at 07:45, Jacob Wegelin wrote:
> Alternate title: How can I persuade my students that R is for them?
> Alternate title: Can R replace SAS, SPSS or Stata for clinicians?
> I am teaching introductory statistics to twelve physicians and two veterinarians
> who have enrolled in a Mentored Clinical Research Training Program. My course is the
> first in a sequence of three. We (the instructors of this sequence) chose to teach
> R rather than some other computing environment.
> My (highly motivated) students have never encountered anything like R. One frankly
> "Do you feel (honestly) that a group of physicians (with two vets) clinicians will
> be able to effectively use and actually understand R? If so, I will happily call this
> bookstore and order this book [Venables and Ripley] tomorrow."
> I am heavily biased toward R/S because I have used it since the first applied statistics
> course I took. But I would love to give these students some kind of objective information
> about the usability of R by non-statisticians--not just my own bias.
> Could anyone suggest any such information? Or does anyone on this list use R who is
> a clinician and not really mathematically savvy? For instance, someone who doesn't
> remember any math beyond algebra and doesn't think in terms of P(A|B)?
> Or have we done a disservice to our students by choosing to make them
> learn R, rather than making ourselves learn SAS, Stata or SPSS?
> Thank you for any ideas
> Jake Wegelin
> R-help at stat.math.ethz.ch mailing list
> PLEASE do read the posting guide! http://www.R-project.org/posting-guide.html
I can give you my experience on this subject. First of all I am not a
Stats/Maths professional, I'm a Marine Biologist working in fisheries,
although with a MSc in Stats ... but I've started using R before I did
In the Fisheries Scientists Community R is becoming broadly used and
most scientists have backgrounds in Biology or similars.
I think the most important question is "are they afraid of the command
line ?" if yes forget about R, otherwise I guess they will love it when
they'll find how much they can do with it.
Hope it helps
More information about the R-help